Pelham Diner
& Grill
Classic American breakfast, hearty burgers, and honest comfort food served with a smile at 138 Fifth Ave.
The Menu
Generous portions, fair prices, and everything made fresh to order. Prices are approximate — see the full menu in-store.
Breakfast All Day
- Buttermilk Pancakes$11
Fluffy stack with warm maple syrup & butter
- The Pelham Classic$13
Two eggs, bacon, hash browns, toast & coffee
- Western Omelet$14
Ham, peppers, onions, cheddar, home fries
- French Toast$12
Thick-cut challah, cinnamon, powdered sugar
- Avocado Toast (V)$12
Sourdough, smashed avocado, tomato, chili flakes
From the Grill
- Diner Cheeseburger$15
1/2 lb angus, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, fries
- Grilled Chicken Club$16
Bacon, avocado, tomato, garlic aioli
- Patty Melt$15
Rye, caramelized onions, swiss, thousand island
- Reuben$16
House-brined corned beef, kraut, russian, rye
- Veggie Burger (V)$14
House-made bean patty, avocado, sprouts
Comfort Plates
- Meatloaf Dinner$18
Mashed potatoes, gravy, seasonal veg
- Chicken Souvlaki$17
Pita, tzatziki, Greek salad, rice
- Fish & Chips$19
Beer-battered cod, tartar, coleslaw
- Mac & Cheese$13
Three-cheese, herbed breadcrumbs
(V) = vegan · Ask your server about daily specials and gluten-free options.
A Pelham tradition, one plate at a time.
Pelham Diner and Grill is the kind of place where regulars are greeted by name and the coffee pot is never far. We serve honest American food — breakfast anytime, big juicy burgers off the grill, and comfort classics that taste like home.
Whether you're stopping in before work, meeting friends on the patio, or feeding the whole family on a Sunday morning, we're glad you're here.
Loved by the neighborhood
"Best diner breakfast I've had in years. The pancakes are unreal and the coffee just keeps coming."
"Cozy neighborhood spot with huge portions and fair prices. Their patty melt is a must-order."
"Friendly staff, quick service, and they actually have great vegan options. New family favorite."
Visit the Diner
We're right on Fifth Ave in the heart of Pelham. Walk-ins welcome — we don't take reservations, because there's always room at the counter.
- Phone
- (914) 738-1399
- Hours
- Open daily · 7:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Good to know
- Outdoor seating · Vegan options · Walk-ins only